Bad Shepherd Brewing
from Australia (Victoria)
Highest RatedOatmeal Stout (73 / 100) Average score61 / 100 (Decent)
Lowest RatedBigsi's Baltic Porter (50 / 100) Number Tried3
Bigsi's Baltic Porter
Reviewed by LaitueGonflable on 27.02.18 on tap
50 / 100
Baltic Porter brewed with Liquorice, Aniseed and Sambuca for GABS 2017. Tried at the festival on tap.

Pours a brown colour with a fair darkness to the edge. Beige foamy head, retaining alright. Looks fairly standard.

Smells dark-malty upfront, with chocolate and dark fruit notes. Aniseed comes through distinctly yet strangely weak, with some clove notes as well. Liqueury-sweet as well, which is not great.

Taste is also weakly Sambuca-esque. Chocolate and a slight nutty edge upfront on the malt, develops some earthy coriander and star anise towards the mid and then finishes sweet and liqueury with a slightly watery edge as well. Not a whole lot of beer character, tastes like a watered-down anise spirit.

Decent texture; has a slight carbonation edge which helps lift it out of potential wateriness.

Pretty unimpressive beer overall. Blandly aniseedy and could really use more porter character throughout as the malt base feels just like a vessel to pour some Sambuca flavour into.
appearance: 3.25 | aroma: 2.75 | taste: 3.0 | feel: 3.5 | drinkability: 3.0
Oatmeal Stout
Reviewed by LaitueGonflable on 13.12.17 in bottle
73 / 100
(Very Good)
Day 2 of my #fletchmas Beer Advent Calendar.

Pours a dark cola colour, with a nice tightly-packed head of light beige bubbles, thin but attractive. Retains a light film on the top, and some thin lacing trails. Looks pretty good.

Smells roasty, like a good espresso, but lightly sour/weak like a brown ale, like the malt base is a little lighter than it could be. Hint of some meaty smoke character as well, with a light cherry note as well. Nice, if a little timid in its milieu.

Taste is a little ballsier, in a good way. Roasty from the get-go, there's plenty of that deep espresso spice with a hint of burntness on the front. That smoke character comes through stronger on the mid, which makes me think it's actually part of the malt bill rather than just a by-product. I may be wrong though as the finish is mostly just dark malt; nice smooth chocolate character towards the finish and ends with a nice bite of roasty bitterness; yes, very pleasant palate all told.

Mouthfeel is a little fizzy; the carbonation sizzles through the malt base which belies a little thinness. Ultimately fluid but a little too busy in the mouth.

Drinks well though, and it's an amazing coincidence that the weather's turned shit on dark beer day. Good roasty notes, and good malt balance with it; not sweet but a good mix of character.
appearance: 3.75 | aroma: 3.5 | taste: 4.25 | feel: 3.25 | drinkability: 4.0
Choc Banana Split
Reviewed by LaitueGonflable on 10.08.16 on tap
62 / 100
Brewed for, and tried at, GABS in Melbourne, May 2016.

Pours a brown colour, slightly cloudy with nice beige lacing. Head looks gorgeous. Generally looks good.

Smells of banana, yeah. Notes of vanilla-caramel, chocolate and a slight cinnamon sweet-spice note as well. Candied, sweet caramelised banana though. Banana icecream. I wish I liked banana more because it's really dominant here.

Taste is sweet upfront. Chocolate, caramel and a touch of vanillin oak towards the mid. Back palate is quite medicinal. There's banana on the front but it just declines and the sweetness doesn't retain so the back is quite phenolic and strong. Bit of a shame.

Decent body, slight alcohol warmth. Not bad.

I'm not a big fan of banana, but the overall desserty sweetness had me intrigued until that bitter, medicinal finish. Just feels like the intentional adjuncts lost control to some by-products of fermentation, sadly.
appearance: 4.25 | aroma: 4.0 | taste: 3.25 | feel: 3.5 | drinkability: 3.25